Skip to main content

Decoding Religion

“2 naans and 1 paneer makhani. Aaj itna hi bhaiya”.

“Ek butter chicken bhi bhaiya”, said A.

“Aaj Tuesday hai, have you forgotten? Aaj ka din shubh nahin hota for nonveg”, exclaimed a shocked T.

“I eat everything, every day. Shubh, ashubh is made by us. God ne kab yeh bola?”

“Aren’t you scared of not following our religion?”

“I am scared of following religion.”, said A with finality much to the shock and confusion of T.

Mulling over this thought, A. kept wondering why it seemed so unlikely and confusing to most people. It seemed simple to her, very straightforward. She could not make head or tail out of most things that were preached. She was willing to understand and follow, but no one had answers to give. No one needed answers or reasons it seemed. They wanted to toe the line. She wanted to understand the teachings, and never figured out how asking questions becomes not ‘toeing the line’. And hence began her skepticism for anything and anyone overtly religious.

The tendency to question and the curiosity to understand was innate to A. It was also something that was nurtured heavily in her upbringing. One of her fondest memories as a child was her post-dinner walks with her mother –  walking on a long stretch of dimly lit road, with rows houses on one side, and an empty ground with a huge peepal tree, twinkling with hundreds of fireflies, on the other. On one such walks, they were discussing the other side of the epics – where Draupadi could have been a bit wrong in her comments, Dronacharya could have been unfair on Eklavya, Ravana had another dimension to his personality and more such. These conversations had sub-consciously stayed with her and increased her desire to question anything that was deemed to be accepted without a flicker of doubt.

Religion was another such topic. It made very little sense to her. What made it worse was that somehow it was just meant to be followed and accepted without knowing why. No one really knew why. Why is Monday fasting for a husband and Thursday for a son? Which days are for a wife/daughter?Why should you not wash hair or eat non-veg on Tuesdays? Why can a girl not wear white? Who decided it was a bad omen and why? And many more such rituals which she wanted to understand before following, but no one seemed to know the reason behind them.

This episode with T. brought back another memory for A. While visiting a very famous shrine, her family had found the experience very unsettling. The shrine was unorganised and dirty, with most people stepping on the ‘holy offerings’ and washing off dirt in the ‘holy water’. At a discussion around this with another family at dinner, the visiting aunty mentioned how she was deeply religious and God-fearing and despite everything cannot stop herself from taking a dip in that ‘holy water’. At this point, A.’s father asked why we went to shrines or needed a religion at all? Wasn’t it to feel peaceful, protected and have a direction of moral living? How does a messy place of worship provide peace and protection? Why should the following a practice become so big that there is oversight in maintaining hygiene? Those words stayed back with A.

She was also reminded of her childhood when she visited a famous shrine with her family. It was the first day of the season when the shrine opened its doors for worshippers and needless to mention, it was packed with devotees. As the gates opened and the ‘devotees’ scrambled in to get a glimpse of their God, A. lost the grip of her mother’s hand and got drowned in the ensuing stampede. She saw her parents pushed into shrine and gates closing behind them while she was struggling to breathe as she got squashed, trampled and strangled in the crowd. It took the priest to step out of the gates and call out for calm to find her; for her to be found and handed back to her parents inside. It lasted only a few minutes but it was bad enough to shake her up and wonder what would have happened if a few more minutes had passed. A. fell sick the next day but the bigger illness was the question tormenting her mind – why was ‘seeing’ their God a race? What happened to the values of patience, love and respect that religion is also supposed to teach us?  ‘Devotees’ were throwing the holy offerings in that direction when gates opened, and the ‘holy’ offerings were just getting trampled on. It was food, good food and milk which could have fed someone. There were flowers which would have been much more useful in any garden. 

Does a religion really say that it’s ok to desecrate the place of faith but insist on discriminating against those of other faith? Why do we believe that God wants constant praises, or a things done only in a particular way by everyone to love His own? Religion to her mind had lost track of what it was supposed to be and had become something everyone followed but no one understood. Maybe the practices made sense in another era but not now. Maybe they make sense even now but no one knows how and why. Maybe the practices were meant to imbibe discipline and kindness, and instead have now become a burden that must be carried because that’s expected. Maybe scriptures and rituals had some meaning which had got lost, and now personal interpretations decided the right and wrong?How else do you explain deeply religious people who are far from peace? People who follow all rules and are the angriest, unhappiest lot that you can come across. If all the prayers have not led to prosperity or health or happiness, then why not understand where the whole thing has gone wrong? If God is supposed to reside in all of our hearts, then why are our hearts not the shrines that we visit to find peace and solace?

As The Dalai Lama says, ‘The only religion is a good heart’. A. wondered if such a world will ever exist.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Tweets Who?

Feminism - a long way to go

An Ode to the Midlife Crisis